The 1979 alt-history novel
Malafrena, set in Le Guin's fictional Central European country Orsinia in the years leading up to a revolution, was only available from my library as part of
The Complete Orsinia. In addition to the novel, this 2016 omnibus edition includes a new introduction from the author, as well as all eleven stories comprising
Orsinian Tales, two other stories which were anthologized in her 1996 collection
Unlocking the Air, and three short poems, two of which were previously unpublished. So if you love Orsinia, this edition seems to be the definitive way to experience it!
Unfortunately I don't love Orsinia, and I didn't love
Malafrena either, though I didn't dislike it as much as I disliked
Orsinian Tales.
The novel centers on Itale Sorde, a young political activist from the provinces who moves to the capital city and starts a newsletter that is critical of Austrian rule and promotes the restoration of an independent Orsinian monarchy. The narrative is somewhat sprawling, also keeping up with some of the people Itale left behind at home, as well as following various of his friends and associates even when their paths diverge from his.
The things I liked about it were the vivid descriptions of physical setting and what it is like for the characters to be present as events are unfolding. I've never been in a violent political insurrection, and I do not think Le Guin ever was either, but I felt very convinced by the living, breathing details of how she wrote the one towards the end of this book. The confusion, the waiting, the hiding, the crowding and pushing and knocking down, the uncertainty about who is where, who's in charge, and if anyone is winning—it feels real. (The realistic, non-idealized depiction of a battle was also one of the things that stuck with me from
Planet of Exile.)
( The things I didn't like were many of the same things I didn't like about Orsinian Tales. [cut for length and negativity] )